My Lovely Little Crochet Lady and the CPSIA
I first heard mutterings about the attempts to enact legislation for toy safety back in the first part of 2007. I was in the know so early because Oregon was sandwiched between California and Washington. California was enacting legislation that would leave children’s merchandiser’s at constant risk of litigation for non-compliance with heavy handed safety regulations. Washington was facing legislation with similar types of materials regulations, but the means of enforcement was proposed to come from government agencies, not the litigious nature of John Q Public. These bills would pass. It was an election year, and no politician could vote no on a safe toys bill.
It became apparent that a national standard would have to be set if the toy industry was going to survive. I was hopeful that the powers that be would come up with a well-thought-out, finely crafted piece that made sense. I was hopeful that we would adopt the standards that have been serving European countries so well.
I have been deeply saddened, horribly troubled, and moved to action by what was enacted instead. My store, on the surface, looks very much like it did before the CPSIA standards were enacted. My numbers look very different. I am selling far less domestic and European product. I am selling far less from my small-batch suppliers. I am unable to sell toys that are handmade by local artists and craftspeople like I did before.
The products that I have that are produced by large manufacturers have not gone up in price the way the products of smaller manufacturers have due to the cost of testing; therefore, they turn faster and the little
guys’ stuff turns slower. When I call, e-mail and fax my state representatives, it is for the industry, not for my store. It is for the manufacturers who are jumping through hoop after hoop just to get products to me. It is for my lovely little crochet lady and her tea sets. I fax, and I call, and I e-mail. Then, I open a newspaper, or turn on the radio, and am dumbfounded by the enormity of all that is happening right now. How busy this world is with interests far more pressing than toys, and I wonder if we stand a chance of being heard at
all.
My fear is that the offerings of toys will finally be whittled down to the top 40 manufacturers, and everyone from Wal-Mart to FAO Schwarz will have to source the same things from the same places, manufactured as cheaply as possible. My hope is that we will be able to change the legislation to something closer to the EU standards so our European manufacturers will be able to sell here and also that the current economic crisis will wake the nation up to the importance of supporting industry on their own soil and that domestic manufacturers of toys will thrive.
I am certain that somewhere between my hopes and my fears lies the final resolution.










[...] manufactured as cheaply as possible.” [Linda Hays (Hopscotch Toys, McMinnville, Ore.), ToyDirectory.com] More views from toyland: Handmade Toy Alliance and Cecilia Leibovitz; Rick Woldenberg in Roll Call [...]
….My fear is that the offerings of toys will finally be whittled down to the top 40 manufacturers, and everyone from Wal-Mart to FAO Schwarz will have to source the same things from the same places, manufactured as cheaply as possible….
I found this remark striking and insightful, as it pertains to the rarely talked about fact that one of the reasons the TIA and other so-called industry “leaders” originally pressed so hard for CPSIA-style regulation was to drive “up production costs, which helps large companies like Mattel and hurts samll toy makers–particularly those sporting ‘Made in America’ labels.” http://tinyurl.com/pfhmtg Small businesses were thrown under the bus by industry big-wigs–and the hypocrisy of their latent attempts to befriend (and incite) small manufacturers never ceases to amaze me.
Having said that, I am confidant that the new leadership at the CPSC will do a much better job at implementing the CPSIA, and that a fair and “final resolution” as you say is in the offing.
Thank you so much for your thoughtful and insightful post. We at the Handmade Toy Alliance (www.handmadetoyalliance.org) have been working hard as well at enacting common sense changes to the CPSIA. We all agree that safety for our children is so very important, but the way the CPSIA is written does little to improve safety standards and insteads penalizes the very companies that work so hard to present unique and safe items for children. Although new leadership at the CPSC is a positive first step to change, there are so many things that need to happen to make this law functionable. Harmonization with EU standards, component testing certification, more material exemptions and an overall look at risk assessment as it pertains to children’s products are critical to keeping small businesses open.
What do you think?
Categories
Tag Cloud
Alex ASTRA best sellers Blue Orange Games books Chamber of Commerce community contest CPSIA creative activities customer concern customer service Duncan Easter eco-friendly economy educational erasers gifts Green Toys Klutz local music natural networking organic Schoenhut Scholastic shop local small business small toys SpongeBob Sprig Toys stores closing support teaching toys Thames & Kosmos toy donation Toy Fair 2009 toy safety Twitter Webkinz yo-yo Yomega YoYoJamArchives
Links
Meta
Recent Posts
Most Commented
Most Viewed